is widely considered the best overall choice due to its sustainable pole-and-line catching methods and consistently high taste-test rankings. Best Canned Tuna Brands at a Glance Key Highlight Estimated Price Best overall taste & sustainability Safe Catch Elite Wild Lowest mercury (tests every fish) Ortiz Bonito del Norte Best premium "splurge" (oil-packed) Tonnino Highest rated for flavor in olive oil American Tuna Best USA-sourced & eco-friendly 365 (Whole Foods) Best store brand for texture Top Recommendations by Category Best for Health (Low Mercury): Safe Catch Elite Wild Tuna Go to product viewer dialog for this item.
: Look for "Pole and Line" or "Troll Caught" to ensure sustainable practices that protect dolphins and turtles.
: Oil-packed tuna is richer and better for salads where the fish is the star (like Niçoise), while water-packed is leaner and better for traditional mayo-based tuna salad. How To Pick The Best Canned Tuna At The Store what is the best canned tuna to buy
The best canned tuna to buy depends on whether you prioritize , sustainability , or low mercury levels . For a top-tier balance of all three, Wild Planet Skipjack Wild Tuna Go to product viewer dialog for this item.
: Skipjack is naturally lower in mercury than Albacore because it is a smaller species. Tonnino Yellowfin Tuna Go to product viewer dialog for this item. is widely considered the best overall choice due
: Certified sustainable by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC), it offers high protein and a clean, fresh taste. What to Look for on the Label
(in Olive Oil) : Consistently wins taste tests for its rich, meaty texture and lack of "fishiness". Reviewers from Serious Eats : Oil-packed tuna is richer and better for
: Praised by The Kitchn for being "tuna-salad ready" with flavorful, high-quality fillets.